Pizza Stone vs Baking Steel vs Carbon Steel Pan (Tested at Home)

The internet is split on the best surface for home pizza. Stone purists insist on cordierite. Modernists swear by baking steel. A growing group has discovered that a regular carbon steel pan, used with the stovetop-broiler method, beats them both.

We made the same pizza three times on three surfaces. Same dough recipe, same oven (a standard residential gas oven, 550°F max), same toppings, same cook time. Here's what happened.

The Setup

Pizza Stone

Cordierite, 15-inch round, $40. Preheated on the middle oven rack for 60 minutes at 550°F.

Baking Steel

1/4-inch thick carbon steel, 14x16 inches, $100. Preheated on the top rack for 60 minutes at 550°F.

Carbon Steel Pan

12-inch CrepePro carbon steel pan, $90. Preheated 5 minutes on stovetop over medium-high, then broiled on the top rack at 550°F.

The Dough

500g bread flour, 325g water, 10g salt, 2g instant yeast, 10g olive oil. Cold-fermented 24 hours. Same dough on all three.

The Toppings

Crushed San Marzano tomato sauce (cold), low-moisture mozzarella, fresh basil after baking, olive oil drizzle.

The Results

Pizza Stone

  • Crust: Decent. Bottom was crisp but not as dark as the others. Some pale patches where the stone had cooled in spots.
  • Top: Cheese melted evenly. No char on the rim.
  • Cook time: 8 minutes
  • Score: 6/10 — fine, but unimpressive

Baking Steel

  • Crust: Excellent. Deeply browned with leopard spotting on the bottom. The steel transferred heat aggressively into the dough.
  • Top: Cheese fully melted, slight bubbling. Rim showed light char.
  • Cook time: 5 minutes
  • Score: 8.5/10 — very good

Carbon Steel Pan + Broiler

  • Crust: Excellent. Same leopard-spotted bottom as the baking steel because of stovetop preheat.
  • Top: Heavily charred from broiler proximity. Cheese bubbled and developed brown spots.
  • Cook time: 6 minutes (3 stovetop, 3 broiler)
  • Score: 9/10 — the most pizzeria-like result

Why the Pan Beat the Steel

Both produced great bottoms. The differentiator was the top. A baking steel sits on the middle rack so the top of the pizza is 8-10 inches from the broiler. The carbon steel pan sat on the top rack with the broiler 4-6 inches above. That proximity gave the top a Neapolitan-style char that the steel couldn't match.

You can replicate the carbon steel pan's setup with a baking steel by putting the steel on the top rack — but then you need 60 minutes of preheat, you can only fit one pizza at a time, and the steel weighs 15+ pounds. The pan does the same job with 5 minutes of preheat and zero compromise.

Honest Trade-offs

When the Pizza Stone Wins

  • You already own one and don't want to buy more gear
  • You want to bake bread (stones excel at bread)
  • You like the ritual of a long preheat

When the Baking Steel Wins

  • You want to make pizzas larger than 12-13 inches
  • You want to make multiple pizzas back-to-back (5+ pies)
  • You're hosting pizza parties

When the Carbon Steel Pan Wins

  • You make pizza for 1-4 people
  • You want the same pan to do crepes, eggs, steak, and stir-fry
  • You don't want a 15-pound slab living in your oven full-time
  • You want the closest-to-Neapolitan result possible in a home oven

Cost-Per-Use Math

Assuming you make pizza twice a month for 5 years:

  • Pizza stone: $40 ÷ 120 pizzas = $0.33 per pizza, single use
  • Baking steel: $100 ÷ 120 pizzas = $0.83 per pizza, single use
  • Carbon steel pan: $90 ÷ 120 pizzas + 500+ other meals = $0.15 per pizza (and a near-free crepe/egg/sear pan)

The carbon steel pan wins on both performance and cost-per-use because it multitasks.

The Method (For the Pan)

For anyone who wants to replicate our winning setup at home:

  1. Place your oven rack on the top position (about 4-6 inches below the broiler element).
  2. Turn the broiler on high.
  3. Heat a 12-inch carbon steel pan on the stovetop over medium-high for 5 minutes.
  4. Stretch your dough to fit the pan. Drop it in the hot pan — it'll sizzle on contact.
  5. Top quickly: sauce, cheese, toppings, drizzle of oil on the rim.
  6. Cook on stovetop for 2-3 minutes until the bottom is golden (lift edge with spatula to check).
  7. Transfer pan to oven under the broiler. Cook 2-3 more minutes, watching closely.
  8. Remove when cheese bubbles and rim chars.
  9. Slide onto cutting board, slice, serve.

Total time: 5-6 minutes per pizza. No 60-minute preheat. No giant slab of metal living in your oven.

Limitations of the Pan Method

  • Pan size limits pizza size (max 12-13 inches)
  • You can only make one at a time
  • Requires both stovetop and oven access (can't outsource one)
  • If your broiler is weak (some electric ovens), you'll get less char

The Crepe Pan Crossover

The reason this method works is that a properly designed carbon steel pan — the same kind used for crepes — has the right combination of mass, conductivity, and surface for pizza. Crepe pans are typically 12-13 inches, with low sides that let the broiler reach the top of the pizza unimpeded. Our CrepePro 12" kit is specifically designed for crepes but works beautifully for this exact pizza method.

FAQ

Does the pan need to be seasoned for pizza?

Yes — a well-seasoned carbon steel pan releases the cooked pizza cleanly. A new, unseasoned pan or a stripped pan will need at least a few seasoning layers before pizza day.

Will high heat damage the pan?

No. Carbon steel can handle 700°F+. Broiler use is well within tolerance.

Should I use parchment paper?

You can if you're worried about sticking, but with a well-seasoned pan, parchment isn't needed. The pizza will slide right out.

How do I clean the pan after pizza?

Let it cool to warm. Wipe out cheese drips. Deglaze with hot water and scrape with a wooden spatula. Wipe dry, oil, store.

Can I make calzones or stuffed pizzas in the pan?

Yes — they work great. Just fold the dough over the filling before cooking and add 1-2 minutes under the broiler to ensure the inside cooks through.

Back to blog